Greater Pittsburgh Aquarium Society, Inc.
GPASI Home Article Index

 

 

 

 

Getting Started with Planted Aquariums:
Filters, Heat, and Inhabitants

Cavan Allen

Finformation, May 2003

 
Now that we have light, nutrients, and CO2 out of the way, we're on to a few other things that need to be addressed in regard to planted aquariums.

Filtration. As I mentioned in a previous article, any filters should not greatly disturb the water surface. No airstones!

They remove CO2 from the water and are not necessary. While very easy plants like Microsorium pteropus and Java moss can grow in aerated aquariums (much more strongly in better conditions), using airstones when carbon dioxide is being added is counterproductive. Good circulation and water movement are all that are needed and will ensure that nutrients, CO2, and heat are distributed evenly throughout the aquarium.

Canister filters, internal filters, power filters (that aren't too splashy), and powerheads all work well for that purpose. Having the tank water circulate four to five times per hour is enough. Adequate mechanical filtration is important. When in doubt, go with a filter with a larger capacity. Otherwise, dirt can accumulate all over and in between the plants. Fine leaved plants like Myriophyllum and mosses can be dirt magnets when filters get dirty or when tank maintenance is neglected.

Chemical filtration is not necessary in a healthy planted aquarium. You may save your carbon for another tank. While not completely irrelevant, biological filtration is less important than it would be in a non-planted tank because the plants do just as good if not better of a job of removing waste than bacteria. Wet-dry filters can be used for large tanks but will likely necessitate the addition of more carbon dioxide.

Heating. I feel that aquarists often neglect to maintain a water temperature appropriate for aquarium plants. Before obtaining a plant, do some research and find out the proper temperature range (as you should research all its requirements). Not all species frequently seen and kept are tropical. Plants that need lower temperatures will survive and even grow in water that is too warm, but will stay smaller and lack vigor. Water temperature of eighty degrees and higher is far from ideal for many plants. Keeping the temperature in the mid-seventies might not sound like something that would make much of a difference, but it does. Aponogeton madagascariensis and Hottonia palustris are good examples of species that benefit from cooler water.

I recommend a good quality submersible heater, as in my experience, they are more reliable and easier to hide than the kind that attach to the back of the aquarium. During the summer, I remove mine and place a room fan on top of some tall furniture near the tank to keep the lights from warming the tank too much. There really isn’t any room for built-in fans in my setup, but if you’re designing one, consider the possibility that you may need them during hot weather.

Water changes. A water changing routine like one on any other tank is fine as long as an eye is kept on water parameters. I replace ten gallons of water a week in my 30-gallon setup. It is not important to deeply vacuum the gravel. Lightly siphoning on top of and in around the plants to remove mulm is adequate.

Appropriate aquarium inhabitants. Be careful about what kinds of animals go into a planted tank. Many cichlids are not suitable for the same reason that so many other fish are not. They're too big. They will disturb and uproot plantings as well and contribute too much waste. Large and robust plants that are strongly secured MAY be an exception. Herbivory is obviously something to be avoided. Silver dollars have no place in a planted tank! Neither do goldfish.

Although not all fish are such diehard plant consumers, many will have a nibble or two here and there. I had to get rid of an ever-increasing population of Hyphessobrycon columbiensis because of their herbivorous tendencies. Hygrophila polysperma is a good beginner plant but a frequent target of any fish with even the slightest inclination to consume plant matter. They destroyed mine along with Hemianthus and one or two other species. Other tetras, rainbows, and barbs (especially rosy barbs) may do some nibbling, but that is never a certainty. Keeping an eye on things and removing them if necessary is usually the best that can be done.

Some fish introduced to help control algae will go after plants if no algae are present and sometimes when it still is. As I will explain in greater detail in a future article, herbivores are NOT the first line of defense against algae. Siamese algae eaters (Crossocheilus siamensis) are frequently recommended as good consumers of hair algae (which is easy enough to prevent in the first place). They also frequently eat mosses and several other fine leaved plants such as Lagarosiphon madagascariensis, so be careful. Most Loricariid catfish do not belong with plants. Like the cichlids mentioned above, they simply grow too large. Those that don't may inadvertently damage sword plants while scouring them for algae. Otocinclus species are good for cleaning up any light fuzz and are always welcome. If algae is lacking, supplement their diet with algae wafers or other foods. American flag fish (Jordanella floridae) can be very effective consumers of hair algae in new or temporarily unsettled tanks, but there is a distinct possibility that they will devastate the plants when the algae is gone.

As far as fish that are suitable for keeping with plants go, dwarf cichlids like Pelvicachromis
and Apistogramma are great options. They thrive in thickly vegetated aquariums and will
often breed in them. Gouramies, betas, rasboras, pencilfish, and Aphyosemion bivattatum
have all done very well for me, and most small fish that can be considered for community
aquariums and feel comfortable in planted aquarium water should as well.

Next time, I'll cover algae in a bit more detail and talk about some of my favorite plants that
are suitable for people just starting out.

 

 

 

 

Up 5

 

 

Back to Top

Questions or Problems? Contact

 
 

Greater Pittsburgh Aquarium Society, Inc.,
founded in 1947
Home ContactsLinksNewslettersExchangeBAPAHAP
Marketplace
SponsorsArticlesCalendarNext Big Event